PRO Neutrals

The waterproof mascara came off in one gentle pass with just warm water—no tugging around my eyes at all. The cloud-soft fibers really do live up to the name, and the two-sided design means I get a fresh side for my second cleanse.

I was skeptical that just water could take off my waterproof mascara, but the cloud-soft fibers really do catch everything without any tugging. The two-sided design is clever too—I use the smooth side for my eyes and the textured side for my foundation.

My makeup remover wipes were leaving my skin irritated, but this eraser got everything off with just water. The cloud-soft fibers feel gentle but the waterproof mascara didn't stand a chance. One side worked for my face, the other for my eyes, and it was clean in the wash.